Home | About Cathy Duffy | Contact Us
   
 

HOMESCHOOL REVIEWS
Parent Helps / How-To Books
Approaches to Education
Overview of Publishers
Early Learning / Preschool
Bible / Religion
Worldview
Phonics / Reading/ Literature
Composition & Grammar
Handwriting
Spelling / Vocabulary
Math
Math Supplements
Science
History / Geography / Cultural Studies
Unit Studies & All-In-One Programs
Umbrella Programs that Provide Curriculum
Foreign Language
Critical Thinking & Logic
Art, Music, Drama
Electives
Creative Learning
Testing & Special Needs
Catholic Curriculum

Latin in the Christian Trivium

by Gail Busby and Mary Harrington

XL Group

This is a four-year traditional Latin program with some unusual elements. First, it’s a Christian program, using excerpts from the Vulgate translation of the Bible for some of the translation exercises rather than the traditional approach that uses ancient Roman writings dealing with war and pagan mythology. It does include a few passages from Caesar and Cicero so that students will have some exposure to the classical style of Latin. It also incorporates quite a bit of history and geography so students become familiar with the classical culture. Ecclesiastical pronunciation is used on the companion CDs or audiotapes (one for each volume).

Since the authors are Protestant, the vocabulary does not include some of the religious vocabulary common to Latin programs with Catholic origins. The program should work well across denominational lines. The only thing I spotted that might be at all controversial among Christians was “The Gospel Road” exercise listing key points of the gospel, all quoted from Scripture. (Some might argue that other points ought to be included.)

The second unusual element is that while these courses use paradigms, memorization of conjugations and declensions, and other hallmarks of traditional courses, Latin in the Christian Trivium also uses a key element of the Principle Approach, creation of a student notebook. Students write into their notebooks such things as Latin phrases and their translations, declension and conjugations “charts,” and vocabulary words. Notebooks also are used to store study sheets, drill sheets, exercises, and tests.

A third element, creation of a vocabulary card file, was borrowed from Writing Road to Reading methodology. It results in a collection of flash cards for easy and frequent review.

A fourth feature that enhances the program was inspired by the Ecce Romani textbooks--a continuing story line about a Roman family. However, this story is based on an actual historical figure, the Roman centurion we encounter in the gospels. The centurion is given the name Romulus Fidelius, and he is blessed with a family who accompanies him as they move to Rome, then from Rome to Judea where he encounters Jesus. Thus, the story serves as a means of tying together the Roman culture and historical Christian/biblical content with an apologetics flavor.

The ongoing story and use of Scripture make this course most markedly different from secular courses in the third year where students typically get a heavy dose of Caesar, Cicero, and mythology.

In addition, lessons have extra sections devoted to special topics that arise in relation to the readings. Students might learn about Roman law, Gnosticism, emperors of Rome, Jewish feasts, and other topics that enrich their understanding.

Probably one of the most appealing features for many parents will be that the program is designed so that even teachers with no Latin background can easily teach it. In fact, older students can probably work through the volumes independently for the most part. Parents will probably need to go over some of the initial work, ensuring that students create their notebooks and vocabulary card files properly. They need to also make sure students understand the basic lesson procedures. These are laid out in very clear detail in each teacher’s guide on a single page at the beginning of each chapter.

For most volumes of the program there are a student textbook; a Study, Drill and Test Sheets booklet; a teacher’s guide; pronunciation CD; and an optional activity book. The activity books feature crosswords, logic puzzles, word searches, mazes, and other such activities that reinforce vocabulary. These are certainly useful but not absolutely essential. Overhead map transparencies (a set of 11 covering all four volumes) are available for those teaching in a classroom setting.

My impression is that this is a very solid Latin program that is likely to be effective because of the multiple methods used to reinforce learning. However, those multiple methods do mean that students are required to do quite a bit of writing along with significant study and memorization.

The teacher’s guides include all the student text pages including study sheets, drill sheets (which might have been called exercises), and tests. Answers are overprinted in a different font. Complete translations are provided where such assignments are given. The books I received also came with a brief “Quick Start Guide” telling you what materials you need and how to set up a revolving two-week schedule for covering each chapter.

You might begin the courses with junior high students, but these really are high school level courses on a college prep level. At the end of the third course, students are supposed to take the National Latin Examination for either or both of Latin II and III. One such exam for Latin II is included as a study sheet. Aside from familiarity with mythology, students should be well prepared for these exams. Volume IV spends much more time on translation of classical authors’ writings.

Although the program really looks easy to use, the authors have made available free online tutoring assistance if a student needs help.

The prices might seem a bit high, but when you actually get into the courses, you will find that the prices are fully justified. The rich variety of content is comparable to one of the best secular programs, the Jenney series, but at far less cost. For Christians, the nature of the content makes it even more appealing than the Jenney series.

Pricing and Purchasing
Price comparison by bookspree.com
  vol 1 vol 2 vol 3 vol 4

textbook

$29.95 $42.95 $48.95 $43.95
study, drills, tests booklet $19.95 $19.50 $24.50  
teacher’s guide $34.95 $52.95 $59.95 $43.95
pronunciation CDs $8.95 $8.95 $8.95  
activity book $13.95 $13.95 $14.95  
map transparencies $24.50      
 
Instant Key

Suitable for: group or one-on-one instruction, shifting toward mostly independent study for older students
Religious perspective: Christian-Protestant

Publisher Info

XL Group

5707 Santa Fe Ave.
San Diego, CA 92109

858.335.6311
www.homeschoollatin.com

Copyright 2007-2008 - Cathy Duffy

Home | Updates for 100 Top Picks | General Book Reviews | Articles | About Cathy Duffy
Contact Us | Submit Products for Review | Ordering

Cathy Duffy/Grove Publishing

[Note: please do not call to order curriculum and other products that we have reviewed.
Contact information for the publisher and ordering is in the right hand column of each review.
Links to Amazon and CBD sometimes appear in the price information.]

16172 Huxley Circle
Westminster, CA 92683

 

Ecommerce Web Hosting by YourHost.com